The Critical Path /
eMail Newsletter
Provocative Musings for the Irreverent
Product DeveloperIssue
6.8 / October 29, 2004
Contents:
-
TCP 2004 Holiday
Gift Guide
<read>
- HyperLinks:
Separated at Birth? <read>
- Top Ten
Product Development Koans <read>
- MRT NewsBriefs
- CoDev Survey
<read>
- Calendar of Events
<read>

Congratulations
to the
Boston Red Sox
2004 World Series Champions!
TCP 2004 Holiday Gift Guide
Yup, it’s already time to start procrastinating on your holiday
shopping. Personally, I think Christmas (and similar holidays)
should come every other year, with your birthday celebrated on the
opposite, just to make life a little easier, but I don’t think I
could make it happen. With Yankee Swaps and Secret Santas just
around the corner, what we can do is point you to some gifts I think
would be appreciated by product development people, from the
gadget-loving techno-geek to the office desktop toy collector, with
something for just about every budget. Please be assured TCP
receives absolutely no remuneration for these recommendations, they
are not commercial endorsements, merely suggestions…just doing our
part to jumpstart this economy…
TCP’S TOP GIFT PICK:
REPLAY-TV
ReplayTV Digital
Video Recorder (DVR) – price range: $50-$600
Never
heard of ReplayTV? This is the Pepsi to Tivo’s Coke, and, while less
popular, it’s the better device for tech-minded individuals. I’ve
been a ReplayTV user for about 6 years now, and can honestly say,
even if you don’t like or approve of television, you need one of
these, it could even make haters like TV. I won’t get into the
features, there are too many, and that kind of talk usually just
goes way over the heads of people who aren’t familiar with DVRs.
Suffice it to say, it is surprisingly liberating to have an
intelligent automated recording agent that is not limited by
videotape’s tiny capacity, to be able to watch something you’ve
recorded before it’s finished recording (unlike a VCR), to be able
to instantly skip over unwanted content (fantastic for sports fans),
and to pause live TV when the phone rings or you just want to go to
the bathroom without waiting for a commercial break. That is just
surface scratching, however, and I won’t even mention being able to
manage recordings over the web when you travel. This is one of the
few pieces of technology that I can say actually lives up to the
hype, and I don’t say that lightly. Prices have plummeted lately
(as much as 75%), so these things are a great value today.
ScotteVest
Tech-Clothing – jacket prices starting at $129.00

Perfect for the gadget freak with the overloaded utility belt. The
ScotteVest jacket got a lot of press when it was first introduced a
few years ago, and gives off a very “James Bond-ish” vibe (or
perhaps “Secret Squirrel-ish” is more analogous). The signature
jacket (now up to version 3.0) boasts up to 42 hidden pockets, a
“personal area network” for wiring devices and headphones through
the material, and many other unique features. Even better, it looks
like a normal jacket, so you can be subtle about your geeky
tech-addictions, but I’m unsure about how well it hides unsightly
PDA bulges. The company now also makes pants, a baseball cap and a
new jacket with solar panels for recharging devices with USB ports.
As the Charlie Chan impersonator on “Get Smart” used to say,
“Amazing…”.
USB Memory Watch - $79.99 - $189.99
The
portable memory market is still going strong--the little flash keys
were instant marvels when they first hit the scene and are
considered must-haves for most computer users today. Product
evolution and “gadgetification” seemed natural for this technology,
and since the beginning of time people have loved to make watches do
all kinds of stuff besides their main function. In the future,
expect to see more funky flash memory products, I think I’ve seen
Simpson’s licensed USB keys somewhere, and you know the Japanese
slapped Hello Kitty on one of these in a New York Yankees
minute.
iPOD – Protective Case System - $29.95
To
be honest, I don’t know why the iPOD is so popular other than the
fact that Apple is marketing the holy heck out of it so you can’t
ignore the thing. I have to admit, though, that the U2 branded unit
is a brilliant idea even if it turns out to be a flop. Around MRT,
we considered an MRT iPOD with all of our product development
audioconferences pre-loaded. We considered it for about 10 seconds.
Anyways, my brother loves his iPOD, so I’m considering getting him
one of these protective case systems, which I like because it seems
very versatile and functional, with a very user-centered design. The
price seems a little high, so I may use one of the websites listed
below to find a better deal.
Roll-Up Keyboard - $29.99
Many
years ago, in Penton’s Machine Design magazine, I saw a picture of a
prototype of a keyboard much like this one (not sure if it’s the
same company). The one in the magazine was a concept piece, circa
1995, trying to show the future of portable computing, and was meant
for applications in the field, like archeology or military ops. Ten
years later, here’s one you can buy, it’s a bit more 3-D than the
flatter one I remember from the magazine, but it still looks like a
fair solution for mobile people with fingers too fat for laptops and
PDA thumb typing. Maybe the ScotteVest v4.0 will have a keyboard
integrated into the pockets.
Rhinoskin
hard cases for PDAs and other devices – prices variable
I
still don’t own a cell phone or a PDA, one of the many reasons being
that I’m sure I’d lose or break them. If you know some clumsy folks
like me, you might want to get them one of these rigid device cases
from Rhinoskin. They’ve got a model to fit pretty much all the major
brands and models of PDAs, and they also make some soft cases too,
but it’s the sturdy rigid ones that they’re known for. There are
also Rhinoskins for the iPOD and GBAsp. I’d like to see David
Letterman have an elephant step on one of these (does he still do
stuff like that?).
Stocking
Stuffers
If
you’re just looking for some smaller, less expensive, but still
really cool, gifts, we’ve put together a short section of sites that
offer a good assortment of knick-knacks and desk tchotchkes perfect
for the Yankee Swap, Secret Santa, Russian Giftbag Roulette or other
office holiday tradition you’ll be celebrating this winter:
Cube Goodies
We like the “Rollerscape” and the “Fog Blasters”.
Stress Balls
Maybe these are better for after the
holidays…
Magnetic Sculptures
Big selection of ”attractive” items, har har. I know, I know,
puns are lame.
Bargain Finding Websites for
Cheapskates
If
you buy, shop or just browse for products on the Internet, you
quickly realize that prices can vary greatly. When I see something I
want to purchase, I almost always do a little price research first.
Below are some of the websites I’ve found to be very helpful for
making sure you don’t overpay:

HyperLinks:
Separated at Birth?
Engadget and Gizmodo...
Link #1: http://www.engadget.com
Link #2: http://www.gizmodo.com
I’m
a little confused. Both of the websites listed here call themselves
“blogs” – weblog pages on the subject of technology gadgets.
Previously, I understood blogs to be an online journal of an
individual’s thoughts on a particular subject or life in general.
These websites, although they may fit the blog definition, are more
like part real-time magazine, part cutting-edge technology catalog,
and part blog. However, the only real “bloggy” thing I can say about
them is that they’re updated frequently and the editorial can be
daringly off-color (and often quite funny if you appreciate geek
humor). I think I will call these things “blog-zines” (hmmm, kinda
also describes this issue of TCP).
Even stranger, if you click on the first link and then click on the
second link, don’t worry, you aren’t seeing things, these two pages
look virtually identical. I’m pretty sure these are separately
developed enterprises, so it’s pretty odd that they share more than
a few page layout and design similarities. I could handle that,
except that their content is eerily the same as well, with similar
editorial styles on just about the exact same gadgets every day
using the exact same product promo pictures. Weird.
If
you can get over these two strange things, the websites are both
really cool ways to stay on top of the latest gadget technologies
and consumer trends. I find myself quite amazed at the various
things people are inventing using technologies that I thought were
centuries away from being real. In many cases, the gadgets shown are
garage hacks or prototypes, but the majority is real, available
products, mostly electronic devices.

Top Ten
Product
Development Koans
From the MRT zen office temple in the Tibetan
Himalayas
| 10. |
What is the
color of quality? |
9. |
Can value stream
from the tap or is it better from a bottle? |
8. |
If a product loses money, is it still innovative? |
| 7. |
If a defective
product passes QA, and no customer is around, will it still get
shipped? |
|
6. |
Can a logo have
greater value than the thing that bears it? |
| 5. |
What metric
tells you if you have too many metrics? |
| 4. |
Can there still
be a customer, if there is no product? |
| 3. |
What will #3 be,
if I have run out of ideas for this list? |
| 2. |
What is the
sound of customer satisfaction? |
|
...and the number one product development koan: |
| 1. |
If cycle-time is reduced to zero, can
you still improve it? |
Top
Ten List Archive
MRT NewsBriefs
Discover how
well companies are doing at co-development. Are they going to market
faster? Realizing more revenues? Learn what the common obstacles are
and what practices are being employed to overcome them. Compare your
company's experience to others, and understand trends since two years
ago (164 participants). This survey is designed to be completed in about
10-15 minutes, and comprehensive results will be presented at the
January 2005 Co-Development Conference. Whether or not you attend the
conference, all participants will also receive an email with survey
results. Deadline to participate is December 31st
Click here to find out how you can participate
in the survey.
Calendar of Events
To inquire about exhibit and sponsorship opportunities at
MRT events, please contact Beth Schrager at schrager@rcn.com
or by phone at 978-263-9931.
Administrivia
The Critical Path is a free
monthly e-mail newsletter written by:
Gregg Tong
Management Roundtable, Inc.
92 Crescent Street, Waltham, MA 02453 USA
Tel: (781) 891-8080 Fax: (781) 398-1889
Gregg@roundtable.com
Please feel free to forward this publication to any
friends or associates you feel could benefit from its message. We welcome any suggestions,
stories or comments that will help us improve the value of this newsletter. Please contact
me directly with your input at the email address above.
This newsletter and archived issues can be
retrieved directly from our website at the following url: http://www.roundtable.com/Critical_Path/Critical-Path-Index.html
SUBSCRIPTION
INSTRUCTIONS
To begin your FREE subscription, please use the automated form located here or send me an email - gregg@roundtable.com. To
unsubscribe, click the link at the bottom of this page if you received it via
email, otherwise, please send an email to me at gregg@roundtable.com
with "unsubscribe critical path" in the subject line or message body.
NEWSLETTER SPONSORSHIP
The Critical Path is provided free of charge to its readers. Companies that share
our objectives of promoting innovative and thought-provoking product development practices
may sponsor The Critical Path. There is space for a maximum of two sponsor messages per
issue. Please send e-mail to gregg@roundtable.com for a complete list of
sponsorship terms and fees, please click here.
PERMISSION TO REPOST TCP
Applications for permission to make The Critical Path available within a company
or other organization (e.g. by internal mail, corporate Intranet, etc.) are usually
accepted. Please send a request for permission to gregg@roundtable.com
DISCLAIMER
The views, thoughts and opinions expressed in this newsletter are solely those of the
author, and do not reflect the views, thoughts and opinions of Management Roundtable, Inc.
or its affiliates.
For more information on Management Roundtable's
events, publications, and services: http://www.ManagementRoundtable.com
© Copyright 2004 by Management Roundtable, Inc. All rights reserved. |